From the Land of Ice and Snow: The Songs of Led Zeppelin is by far one of the most ambitious album projects to come across my desk this year. The 2-CD set (a third digital bonus album is available) comes from Portland's Jealous Butcher records on October 9th. The album, six years in the making, features Zeppelin covers performed by Portland and area notables with a portion of the proceeds going to
First Octave, an organization the promotes music education.
When it comes to reviewing this record I have to admit that I'm at a bit of a disadvantage. That's because, well frankly, I hate Led Zeppelin. I find their music bloated, self-indulgent, and boring. That earns them a coveted spot right next to Pink Floyd on my "Most Over-rated Bands of All-time" list. That said, it is intriguing to see what bands choose to do with this material.
The tracks that work the best are the versions where an artist takes a song and makes it their own. Whether it's string reinterpretations by The Clampitt Family and The Portland Cello Project, or piano renditions by Nick Jaina, these arrangements add new life to otherwise tired tracks. "Stairway To Heaven" is churned and cleansed until it becomes a fairly good pop rock tune by Kelly Blair Bauman.
The sweet vocal pop of Kaia and the country blues of Lana Rebel do well by stripping out the superfluous wanking of Page and company. That wanking is modernized by Carcrashleander and played almost Minutemen-style by Pellet Gun. Laura Veirs and Mount Analog rock "The Ocean" in a charming way.
Possibly the best track on the album is Knock Knock's tongue-in-cheek take on "Moby Dick". They intersperse goofy snippets among what it otherwise a true to the original version. It seems to me as though they are taking the piss out of a legendary rock band who are too often taken way too seriously.
Other acts choose to highlight aspects of Led Zeppelin's music that reinforces exactly why I dislike them. Among those are Kind of Like Spitting, who's take on "Good Times, Bad Times" verges on unlistenable. Amy Annelle goes to the completely opposite end of the spectrum with a snooze-inducing rendition of "Friends".
Surprisingly, the biggest names on the album contribute some of the least noteworthy tracks. Death Cab For Cutie's Chris Walla drops a plodding dud. Loch Lomond's wandering indie folk only exacerbates "Kashmir"'s interminable feel. M. Ward's instrumental "Bron-Yr-Aur" is pleasant but unremarkable.
Despite the inconsistent nature of the album, not unexpected with a collection this size, the sheer volume of tracks and the cause it helps support make this worth picking up.
Best tracks: "The Ocean", "Black Dog"
Track listing for From the Land of Ice and Snow:
DISC 1
- Good Times Bad Times / KIND OF LIKE SPITTING
- Babe I'm Gonna Leave You / THE CLAMPITT FAMILY
- Dazed And Confused / THE PORTLAND CELLO PROJECT
- featuring LAURA GIBSON & JOHN MOEN
- Your Time Is Gonna Come / NICK JAINA
- Whole Lotta Love / FUKD'UPTIGHT
- Poor Tom / ADAM SELZER
- Nobody's Fault But Mine / CARCRASHLANDER
- Fool In The Rain / KAIA
- Thank You / DAN JONES
- Heartbreaker / LACKTHEREOF FEAT. PETE MCCRACKEN
- Moby Dick / KNOCK-KNOCK
- Out On The Tiles / SUPER XX MAN
- Friends / AMY ANELLE & THE SHISHI VALLEY BOYS
- Tangerine / JEFF LONDON
- Bron-Y-Aur Stomp / ARCH CAPE
- Hey Hey What Can I Do / WEINLAND
- In The Evening / CHRIS WALLA
DISC 2
- Black Dog / LANA REBEL
- Rock and Roll / PELLET GUN
- The Battle of Evermore / TU FAWNING
- Stairway To Heaven / KELLY BLAIR BAUMAN
- Misty Moutain Hop / BUELTON
- Four Sticks / REBECCA GATES AND THE CONSORTIUM
- Over The Hills and Far Away / JOHANNA KUNIN
- No Quarter / TESTFACE
- The Ocean / LAURA VEIRS & MOUNT ANALOG
- Houses Of The Holy / BELTLINE
- Kashmir / LOCH LOMOND
- In The Light / THE LONG WINTERS
- Bron-Yr-Aur / M. WARD
- Down By The Seaside / POWER OF COUNTY
- All My Love / PARKS & RECREATION
- I'm Gonna Crawl / DAVE DEPPER
6.5/10
Jealous Butcher's website